McMaster's Pension Plan

A Performance Review

Actuarial Valuation of the Pension Plan as at July 1, 1998

Excerpts from Report to the Pension Trust Committee
Prepared by William M. Mercer Ltd.

The purpose of the report is to inform the University regarding the funded status of the Pension Plan and the contribution requirements for the year following the valuation date and to provide the documentation prescribed by the Pension Commission of Ontario and Revenue Canada.

When conducting a valuation on a going-concern basis, the relationship is determined between the respective values of assets and accumulated benefits, assuming the Plan will be maintained indefinitely.


FINANCIAL POSITION
The results of the valuation as at July 1, 1998, in comparison with those of the previous valuation as at July 1, 1997, are summarized as follows:


Financial Position -- Going-Concern Basis ($000's)
JULY 1, 1998JULY 1, 1997
Actuarial Value of Assets
(adjusted for in-transit amounts)$836,931$732,280
Actuarial Liability
present value of accrued benefits for:
Active Members$321,504$307,506
Pensioners & Survivors$244,203$234,265
Deferred Pensioners$1,701$1,264
Additional Voluntary Contributions$90$100
Inactive - Status Undecided$10,832$8,540
Total Liability$578,330$551,675
FUNDING EXCESS$258,601$180,605


CURRENT SERVICE COST

The estimated value of the benefits that will accrue on behalf of the active members during 1998/99, in comparison with the corresponding value determined in the previous valuation as at July 1, 1997, is summarized on the next page.

Employer's Current Service Cost ($000's)
JULY 1, 1998JULY 1, 1997
Total Current Service Cost$20,988$20,647
Estimated members' required contributions$5,570 $ 5,605
Estimated employer's current service cost$15,418$15,042
Employer's current service cost expressed as a % of members' contributions 277% 268%

*Members will contribute 50% of this amount during the 1997/1998 and 1998/1999 Plan years. The remainder will be funded through surplus assets in the Plan.



MEMBERSHIP DATA: Plan membership data is summarized below.

Plan Membership
JULY 1, 1998JULY 1, 1997
Active Members2,7362,731
Pensioners and Beneficiaries994970
Deferred Pensioners6054
Inactive-Status Undecided279251
TOTAL MEMBERSHIP4,0694,006




Measurement of Investment Management Performance for the Quarter ending June 30, 1998

Time Weighted Rates of Return

UNIVERSITYQUARTERS ENDINGANNUAL RATESLONGER PERIODS

Sep 1997Dec 1997Mar1998 June 1998Year Ending June 98Jun94- Jun95 Jun95 -Jun96Jun96-Jun97 Jun96- Jun98 Jun95-Jun98Jun94-Jun98
2 yrs3 yrs4yrs
Queen's6.4(2.4)7.7 0.912.812.813.722.1 17.416.115.3
York5.7(2.2)8.4(0.0)12.0 13.213.319.215.6 14.814.4
McMASTER5.60.1 8.01.115.416.214.2 21.718.517.116.8
Carleton6.3(2.6)7.70.6 12.114.313.220.9 16.415.315.1
Brock5.3(0.4)8.30.8 14.412.512.218.6 16.515.114.4
Waterloo6.4(2.1)7.90.4 12.912.614.522.3 17.516.515.5
Windsor4.7(2.4)7.1(0.4) 9.013.313.219.9 14.314.013.8
TSE9.8(4.4)13.3(2.2)16.3 15.314.030.223.1 20.018.8
S&P5007.56.513.16.8 38.324.125.136.5 37.433.230.8
Long TermBonds7.64.24.13.2 20.521.311.121.0 20.717.418.4
Mid TermBonds4.71.22.91.1 10.217.910.714.8 12.511.913.4

Returns include interest income, dividends, currency gains/losses, capital gains and are net of investment expenses.

Prepared by William M. Mercer Limited.




Combined Managers: Asset Commitment Comparables

MARKETVALUE POLICYASSET MIX
Jun97Sept97Dec97 Mar98Jun98MinBench Max
%%%% %%%%
EQUITIES
Canadian (JF/Linc)17.417.216.2 16.516.7
Canadian (Index)12.312.911.7 12.412.1
TOTAL Canadian29.730.1 27.9*28.928.825 3560
U.S. (JF/Linc)10.610.511.3 11.711.410
U.S. (Derivative)***6.46.6 5.15.45.5
Non-N.A.9.89.69.39.8 10.110
TOTAL Foreign26.826.725.7 26.927.0102025**
TOTAL Equities56.556.8 53.6*56.8*55.835 5575
FIXED INCOME
Bonds (JF/Linc)24.625.625.2 25.725.1
Bonds (Index)14.214.114.5 13.914.1
TOTAL Bonds38.8*39.739.7 39.639.22542 50
Cash4.73.56.7*4.6* 5.00315
TOTAL Fixed Income43.543.2 46.4*44.2*44.225 4565
TOTAL FUND100.0100.0 100.0100.0100.0
* change in weighting of +/- 2% since previous quarter
** Maximum of 20% by book value
*** deemed to be Canadian content


COMMENTS

The market value of the Fund increased from $895.3 million on March 31 to $898.8 million on June 30, 1998 after accounting for net cash withdrawals of $6.6 million. Lincluden's portfolio declined as a percentage of the Fund in the second quarter, while Jarislowsky's portfolio increased, primarily because Jarislowsky had better performance than Lincluden.

The above table provides the breakdown of the Fund by asset class. The foreign content, at 27.0%, remains above the Policy maximum of 25.0%, due mostly to the superior performance of US and non-North American equities last quarter compared to Canadian stocks and bonds.

Prepared by James P. Marshall, Inc.